Is Self-Publishing the Right Path for You?

Publishing has transformed dramatically in the last twenty years. What was once a narrow, gatekept-path through agents and publishing houses has become a broad highway paved with possibility. Self-publishing has enabled thousands of writers to bring their books to life on their own terms. But just because anyone can self-publish doesn’t mean it’s the right path for every writer.

So how do you know if self-publishing is the best fit for you?

Let’s break down the key factors to consider—financial, personal, practical, and emotional—so you can make a confident, informed decision about your publishing journey.

In traditional publishing, the publisher covers the costs of editing, design, marketing, printing, and distribution. With self-publishing, you’re the publisher—which means you front the expenses.

The necessary self-publishing costs:

• Editing (developmental, copyediting, proofreading): $1,000–$6,000+
• Cover design: $200–$1,000
• Formatting (for print and ebook): $50–$300
• ISBNs and barcode (if in the US and buying through Bowker): $125 for one or $295 for ten
• Self-publishing platform and distribution: KDP is free but takes 30% of ebook and 6% of paperback revenue. IngramSpark is a one-time $49 enrollment fee, and then they take 14% for pint books and 40% of ebooks. Smashwords is free, then they take 25%.

May not be necessary but may need self-publishing costs:

• Print production: Print-on-demand through Amazon is free. Outside of that, it runs $4–$10 per book.
• Interior book design (for print and ebook): $200–$3,500+
• Marketing and ads: Highly variable, $0 to thousands per month
• Audiobook production: $300–$6,000
• Illustrations and images: $60–$300 per illustration. $600–$10,000 for children’s picture book
• Index: $2.60–$6.00 per indexable page
• Translation: $800–$10,000+
• Author website: Created by a professional would be around $1,500–$4,500

Yes, you can self-publish on a shoestring budget, but the results usually reflect that. Publishing a high-quality, professional book typically costs at least $2,000–$4,000, depending on word count and genre. So ask, Do I have the budget to invest in this book the way it deserves?

If not, are you willing to save, scale back, or learn to DIY some of the tasks? And by learn to DIY, I mean really learn how to do it, not just say you can and then do it poorly. That might mean taking courses, reading how-to books, etc.

Self-publishing is more than writing a book and uploading it to Amazon. It’s a full-on crash course in:

• Publishing platforms (like KDP, IngramSpark, Draft2Digital)
• Print-on-demand logistics
• ISBNs and copyright registration
• Book marketing strategies
• Amazon SEO and metadata
• Author branding
• Launch planning

That doesn’t mean you have to learn it all today. But you either need do to be willing to learn or pay for  someone who already knows.

If you enjoy researching and acquiring new skills, self-publishing offers a rich world of discovery. But if the idea of learning Amazon’s metadata system or email list building makes you want to cry, you need to build a strong support team before diving it.

That’s the nice thing about self-publishing. You don’t have to go it alone. You can work with professionals or learn from other authors.

But either way you’re sacrificing something: either time to learn or money to have others do it for you.

Self-publishing can be lucrative, but it’s rarely quick or easy. Often you won’t see a monetary ROI until your second or third book.

Self-publishers get a much higher royalty rate—typically 60–70% for ebooks and 40–60% for paperbacks, depending on platform and distribution choices. Compare that to traditional publishing, where you may earn 5–15% of print sales and 25% of ebooks (after your advance is earned out).

That said, many self-published books sell fewer than 100 copies. Without name recognition, a large audience, or a marketing plan, your book may be beautifully written and professionally packaged yet invisible in the sea of 4,000+ new books published every day.

To sell books consistently as a self-published author, you need:

• A clear audience (know who your book is for)
• A marketing strategy (email list, social media, Amazon ads, book launch plan)
• A long-game mindset (sales often come months after publication)

If your goal is to build a long-term author career, be recognized as a thought leader, book speaking gigs, or generate passive income, self-publishing is a smart investment. But if you’re writing only one book not to get speaking gigs or as a calling card for your business but rather hoping for mainstream bookstore distribution and a monetary ROI, those are often easier to access through traditional routes.

Self-publishing isn’t for everyone. It demands more than just writing chops. The most successful indie authors tend to share a few key personality traits and soft skills:

• Self-Motivation: There’s no agent, editor, or publisher setting deadlines for you. You need to manage your own time and follow through—without external pressure. Essentially, you need to be a go-getter.
• Resilience: You’ll face challenges—tech issues, slow sales, harsh reviews, unexpected expenses—so being able to bounce back and keep going is vital.
• Flexibility: You’ll likely make mistakes. Algorithms change. Strategies evolve. You need to adapt and adjust instead of throwing in the towel.
• Business Mindset: Self-publishing is running a small business. You don’t have to love spreadsheets, but you do need to think in terms of return on investment (ROI), target audience, and long-term planning.
• Curiosity: The publishing world is always shifting. Staying curious and open to new tools, trends, and techniques helps you grow as an authorpreneur.

If you’re naturally proactive, adaptable, and eager to learn, self-publishing could be a great fit.

Self-publishing is not for the faint of heart, but it is a viable route with some great perks you don’t get with traditional publishing.

Self-publishing gives you total creative control. Want a pink cover with sparkles? You can have it. Want to keep a scene that your editor thinks should go? You’re the ultimate decision-maker.

Some authors find this deeply empowering. Others feel paralyzed by decision fatigue.

So ask, Do I want the final say in every aspect of my book, or do I want a team to make those decisions for me?

Of course, you can opt to just trust your professional editors, book designers, etc. and let them make the decisions.

This is the ultimate plus of self-publishing: you get final say. This isn’t the case with traditional publishing.

In self-publishing, you retain full rights to your work, unless you sign them away to a third-party service (always read the fine print!).

This means:

• You can adapt your book into an audiobook, film script, or workbook.
• You can revise and re-release new editions.
• You can republish the same content in different formats or languages.
• You can even pull the book from sale entirely.

In contrast, traditional publishers usually acquire exclusive rights for a period of time (or indefinitely), and they control many decisions about adaptations, pricing, distribution, and marketing.

If owning and protecting your intellectual property matters deeply to you, self-publishing gives you maximum control.

Traditional publishing takes time, often two to three years from finished manuscript to bookstore shelves.

Self-publishing is significantly faster. Depending on your editing, design, and launch prep timelines, you could publish a book in a few months.

This flexibility is especially helpful if:

• You’re writing about a timely topic.
• You want to publish multiple books a year.
• You’re building a content-driven business (like coaching, courses, or speaking).
• You’ve already spent years writing and don’t want to wait anymore.

Just remember: faster isn’t always better. Quality still matters. Rushing through editing or cover design can hurt your book’s reception and long-term sales.

But if you value speed and independence, self-publishing puts you in the driver’s seat.

There’s no shame in deciding self-publishing isn’t your thing. And remember: you’re not locked into one path forever. Many authors pursue hybrid careers, self-publishing some books and traditionally publishing others.

Your publishing journey is yours to define.

Self-publishing isn’t just a backup plan anymore. For many authors, it’s the best and most empowering way to bring their books to life, connect with readers, and build a sustainable writing career.

But it’s also a business. One that requires time, energy, investment, and a deep well of persistence.

Before you commit, give yourself space to explore your options, build your knowledge, and clarify your goals. With the right mindset and support, you can publish a book you’re proud of and maybe even build a career you love.

To get notified whenever I publish a new blog, learn useful writing and publishing tips from other professionals, get discounts on my resources, see what I’m reading and recommending, and learn when I have editing openings, sign up for my newsletter.

I’d love to hear from you. Comment below using any of these prompts to guide you:

• What questions do you have?
• What part of the self-publishing journey excites you the most and what feels the most intimidating?
• If you’ve already published (or are planning to), what made you choose self-publishing?
• Which of the key traits or skills mentioned in this post do you already have and which ones do you want to strengthen as you move toward publishing?
• What is one thing you did professionally or personally today that you’re proud of?